Taylor Hale made Big Brother history as the first Black woman to win the show, and y’all, she came into the Throne Room as one of our very first guests and did not hold back. We got into Miss Michigan USA, the Taylor Hale breakup with Joseph Abdin that ended on an actual breakup cruise, why she cut off two exes in January, her Playboy cover, The Traitors, and why she doesn’t believe in forgiveness. Detroit’s own came to play.

From Miss Michigan USA to Big Brother History

I have to be real with you guys: I wasn’t watching Big Brother when Taylor won. Everybody in their mama was tagging me, telling me we were about to have our first Black woman win, so I went back and watched the whole season straight through. I’ve been a Big Brother fan ever since.

What shocked me is that Taylor didn’t even get into pageants until her senior year of college. She was flipping channels over winter break, landed on Miss Universe and thought, “I think I could do that.” She made the semifinals in DC, came home to Michigan about three years later and won Miss Michigan USA. She told me she likes to bet on herself. Clearly.

She calls the pageant years her training wheels for being a public figure, right down to grown adults on pageant message boards picking apart her teeth. And she says the live feeds are the only reason her Big Brother story gets told right. People watched her walk in on premiere night and decided they didn’t like how she walked in heels, or that she “smiles too hard.”

She also weighed in on Big Brother 28. She doesn’t think Taylor Brown was crazy for saying Rick Devens had an edge coming in with an established Survivor fan base, but she gave Rick his flowers for doing what he needed to do with every opportunity.

What really got me is how personal her win is for people. Queer fans, people who’ve been bullied, Black women: she says fans fall into her arms crying because they cried with her when she was alone in that house. And she told me she doesn’t care where anyone ranks her among Big Brother winners.

“If every Black woman that gets to play is ranked higher than my gameplay, that’s a win for me, cuz my win meant that they got to be better.”

The Taylor Hale Breakup With Joseph Abdin, on a Breakup Cruise

Now let’s get into it, because y’all know I had to. Taylor and Joseph Abdin met in the Big Brother house, and she told me she was really, deeply in love with him. They were friends before they fell for each other, and when it stopped working, they literally went on a breakup cruise together. They posted on their stories at the same time, put the phones down and just hung out.

So how did she know? She told me about a volunteer trip to Honduras. Joseph loves the boots-on-the-ground work. Taylor would rather throw the gala and get rich people to open their checkbooks. He wanted his person on those trips with him, and that’s when she realized they needed different partners. Not bad people, just not compatible.

Then came the part that surprised me. In January, she stopped talking to Joseph and to her other ex, Kyland Young, who she ran The Amazing Race with. She had nothing but good things to say about both of them. She said they’re both open to friendships with people she doesn’t want in her world, and being adjacent to that was causing her stress. She told me she was on her hands and knees in her loft, sad about letting them go.

Taylor Hale breakup interview in The Throne Room with KEMPIRE

Playboy, The Traitors and the Week Everything Changed

And here’s where it gets crazy. The day after she let them go, she got the call for Playboy. The day after that, The Traitors. The day after that, a call to produce projects she’d been wanting to make happen for a while. She says she’s not religious, but she took it as her sign. She still misses them both, and one of them even sent her flowers when the Playboy news came out.

The Playboy story is full circle. Editor-in-chief Phillip Picardi gave her an informational interview back when she was in college, interning at Essence. Years later he texted asking her to be Miss March, with two weeks’ notice. She said yes on one condition: she got to write the essay that ran with it.

That essay is about something she’d been carrying since the show. She says people would screenshot moments from the live feeds while she was changing or sleeping and spam her with them online. She told me she’s not ashamed of her body, but that’s an issue of consent. She wrote about women’s bodies in public, AI and ownership, and she calls it some of the best writing she’s ever done.

As for The Traitors, she’d been asked since season two, but her Big Brother contract came with a two-year exclusivity window, and last year she picked The Amazing Race, where she and Kyland finished second. This time she said yes. Going in, she knew Big Brother 25 winner Jag Bains, Michele Fitzgerald from Survivor, and had met Q from Survivor in passing. I asked if there’s beef with Jag. Her answer: “You’ll have to watch Traitors and see.”

Never Miss a Story
Get the Latest
Delivered.

New stories and videos every week — straight to your inbox. Pop culture, uncensored.

Why Taylor Hale Doesn’t Believe in Forgiveness

Okay, this one stopped me. Taylor told me, “It’s a little controversial. I don’t believe in forgiveness.” She can accept an apology as authentic and genuine, but to her, forgiveness can feel like validating the behavior, and a little sanctimonious. She thinks accepting an apology carries more weight, because nobody is obligated to. Capricorn energy, y’all. Deep.

On dating in LA, she kept it real: she says it’s tough out there for a dark-skinned Black woman. Her type is “hot and kind,” and she means kind, not just nice for 20 minutes in public. She’s done dating anyone from Big Brother, Survivor or The Amazing Race, especially now that she hosts Big Brother: Unlocked. And yes, I offered myself as backup. She said if it’s not Kelly Rowland, it’ll be me.

Before you go, Taylor is part of Crown of Deceit: Inside the Miss Universe Scandal, which premiered November 12 on TLC, about the dark side of pageants. The extended cut of our conversation, Behind the Throne, is on Patreon at patreon.com/thekempire. And if you want more from the Throne Room, catch my interview with ex-Bravo producer Patrick McDonald.

Disclaimer: This post is based on publicly available information and credited sources. All allegations are unproven