Y’all, I almost didn’t recap this one. Eleven episodes into The Real Housewives of New York City Season 16, I’m giving Episode 11 a five and a half out of 10. It was okay. Just okay. And the reason I’m hovering there is the Carole Radziwill Substack. Carole wrote a whole essay calling Sai De Silva an onion, then showed up to lunch asking if anyone had read it. Meanwhile, Hailey Glassman had the most honest scene of the night with her mom, and Daisy Toye stormed out of yet another party.

The Carole Radziwill Substack: Sai De Silva Is the Onion

Let me start with what annoyed me the most. Devyn Simone asks Sai and Jessel if they’ve seen Carole’s Substack, and it’s an essay about onions. Carole never names Sai, but she describes what happened at Erin’s party with Sai “screaming” her name, so we all know who it’s about. And I’m glad production keeps replaying that clip, because Sai was not screaming. She was saying, “Carole. Carole.”

In the essay, Carole says she prefers to surround herself with apples. She even calls herself a Macintosh. Then she calls Sai an onion: thin-skinned yet sharp, can dish it out but can’t take it. I have to be real with you guys. Metaphors like that land differently when the woman you’re separating from the group is one of the only women of color at that table, and you’ve lined yourself up with Erin and Daisy. To me, it read like a microaggression.

Sai handled it. She said she was happy she could spark Carole’s creativity, and that she thought they had moved on from the Epstein conversation. Then in her confessional she joked that most boomers hold a grudge. Boomers, I need you to weigh in on that one. Some people will call that ageist. I’d still take it over what Carole is doing this season.

What makes it lamer is that Carole spent years talking about how she was above this show, and now she’s self-producing with a Substack. Sai asked if she wrote it with ChatGPT, so Carole scanned it on camera to prove it was 100% written by a human. She didn’t say anything about a ghostwriter, though. Now I’m starting to wonder if Aviva was right.

“Your onion metaphor is giving weirdo. Eleven episodes in, Carole has brought nothing for me.”

Hailey Glassman’s Mom Scene Finally Made Her Make Sense

This was my favorite part of the episode, and that’s the psychology degree talking. Hailey Glassman sits down with her mom at a restaurant full of big, comfy chairs, and her mom’s sciatica is acting up, so she’s testing chairs all over the room. Kooky. And so is Hailey. If neither of them marries anyone else, I can see a Grey Gardens situation.

Then it got real. Hailey says she’s unsatisfied in her marriage to Rubin. Her mom says nobody is perfect and asks what her perfect life would look like, and Hailey doesn’t know. She says she hasn’t been the same since she was 22, that she spent most of her life trying to please her mom, and that Rubin became the buffer between them. I think Rubin set her free from her mom’s control.

Then Hailey brings up dating women. Her mom says she was never against it, and Hailey’s like, since when? She says her mom once said some women are with women because they can’t get guys. Her mom said “some,” but I understand why Hailey heard it as being about her. Hailey’s stuff is her mother wound. My advice: set boundaries now, because what you run from always catches up.

That’s why the lunch with Carole, Daisy and Erin frustrated me. Hailey has a soft spot for Sai because Sai checked on her at Passover, and the group basically tries to pull her to their side. Carole says Hailey’s loyalty to Sai is giving Patty Hearst levels. Daisy asks what Hailey does for a living and where her money comes from. Hailey says she’s a publicist, maybe she comes from money, maybe she’s just good with money. It was giving mean girl, and Carole, the oldest woman at that table, was leading it.

Carole Radziwill Substack on The Real Housewives of New York City Season 16

Jessel’s Bollywood Birthday: Pavit’s Speech and Carole’s “I’m Not a Hugger”

Jessel Taank throws an Indian-inspired, Bollywood-style birthday party, and I loved it, because everyone shows up dressed in every hue looking beautiful. She even has Hailey wear her wedding dress to trick Pavit Randhawa, and he doesn’t recognize it. When they flashed back to their wedding photo, I said, okay, Pavit was cute back then. Lindsay Hubbard also arrives with Erin and Abe Lichy, and I’m not interested in seeing her as a Housewife.

Then Jessel asks if anyone is making a speech about her. Pavit gets up and says her birthdays are really special to her, not so much to him, and that it leads to misunderstandings between them. Happy birthday. Everyone thought it was awkward. I know people are dragging him, but Jessel didn’t seem hurt or bothered at all. Maybe it’s a British thing. Then he brings out a cake he made himself.

Meanwhile, Carole is back at it. She’s telling Devyn she texted Sai and never got a reply when Sai walks up. Carole says Sai was screaming her name “like a lunatic” across Erin’s house, and Sai mimics her in her confessional: Carole. Carole. Devyn tells Carole the essay felt well balanced. Well balanced how, Devyn? You only read the bad parts.

Then Sai goes in for a hug and Carole says she’s not a hugger. In her confessional she says she is a hugger, but only when she’s feeling peace and love. I get it, I’m the same way. But Carole doesn’t seem to realize how this keeps landing with the audience. Sai thought they had moved on. And Carole asking Abe at a birthday party whether he’s had a vasectomy yet? Inappropriate.

Never Miss a Story
Get the Latest
Delivered.

New stories and videos every week — straight to your inbox. Pop culture, uncensored.

Daisy Toye Storms Out of Jessel’s Birthday — Again

Erika Hammond arrives and gives Daisy a memory supplement, and Lindsay calls it an FU gift. Remember, Daisy admitted on the after show that she was invited to Erika’s birthday; she just didn’t like how. Devyn calls Daisy out for being hard on Erika, and Daisy says Devyn has only been around for a hot second. Devyn says that, based on what she’s seen, Daisy has been hard on her. Get her, Devyn.

Daisy says she feels Erika’s friendship with her is a courtesy because of Martha Stewart. Honestly, it might be. Erika later tells Jessel and Lindsay she thinks Daisy thinks she’s Martha Stewart. Then Erika shares that she met her surrogate and her surrogate’s husband, and Erin asks what happens once the baby is here, since Ankur Jain isn’t at the party. Erika says he’s working and they’ll have a night nurse.

Erika felt grilled for sharing good news. But she has said in her confessionals that Ankur wasn’t there while she was sick during egg retrieval, so I wonder what other conversations we’re not seeing. Former Bravo producer Patrick McDonald told me in our Throne Room interview that the show is about 70% producer-driven and 30% real life, so context matters.

Then the blowup. Sai tells Hailey that Daisy is painting her as the bad guy. Hailey says Daisy claimed everyone was talking behind her back, and Daisy says everyone just had questions about Hailey’s life. Those are not the same thing. Daisy goes off, storms out of another party and yells an expletive at the group on her way out. It’s not landing, Daisy. You keep picking fights and running.

That’s all I’ve got for Episode 11. If you missed last week, catch my RHONY Season 16 Episode 10 recap. How would you rate this one?

How would you rate this one?

Disclaimer: This post is based on publicly available information and credited sources. All allegations are unproven