The Real Housewives of New York City Season 16, Episode 9, finally slows down and lets these women tell their family stories, and I have to be real with you guys, that’s exactly why I enjoyed it. I pre-recorded this one because I had a whole day and I wanted to save Salt Lake City for its own moment tomorrow, but even hungry and running on no food, I watched it twice. This wasn’t a bad episode. It leaned into the personal over the manufactured, we learned more about Daisy, Jessel, Erin and Erica than we have all season, and that’s the connective cord New York has been missing. Let me know how you’d rate it from one to ten.

Give Erin Some Grace — She Just Had a Whole Baby

Erin and Abe meet up in the kitchen with their little baby and talk about what actually set off their back-and-forth at his birthday. Here’s the thing. She’s type A, he’s a little more laxidaisical, he just wanted to enjoy his day, he spilled something, and she got frustrated and reprimanded him in front of his friends. I can see why he’d be annoyed, and I can also see her side. Erin says the frustration is really about her son Levi not listening, and she feels like she can’t discipline him. But I never want to rule out what nobody’s mentioning, and that’s postpartum. This baby isn’t even a year old. I think people completely forgot Erin was pregnant going into these last couple of episodes, so when you stack a newborn, a toddler who won’t listen, and hosting a party for a reality show all at once, of course it’s a lot. She apologizes to Abe, and I’m giving Erin grace here. Y’all don’t have to, but this is my review. People like Erin and Abe bicker and still ride for each other, and I don’t see a divorce. I see a marriage.

“She hesitated when they asked if she’s in love with Pavit. I would be upset watching that as her husband.”

Wait, You Paused? On Camera?

Jessel and Sai meet for lunch, and Sai is starting to remember exactly what she didn’t like about Daisy years ago, calling her judgy and a bit of a hater. She didn’t have to tell us that, we watched Daisy do it to Erica, who’s over there giving Cynthia Bailey host energy for no reason to be contrary. Then Jessel opens up about Pavit, and this is where I sat up. She says she grew up keeping things inside, that she doesn’t see ambition from him, and that she thinks he resents her. But when they ask her in her confessional whether she’s in love with Pavit, she hesitates. I said what in the Ray J. I would be upset watching that as her husband, that pause when someone asks if you love me. Is the hesitation for the edit, or is it real? I don’t know if I 100% believe this marriage-trouble storyline at all. Pavit is apparently a full-time influencer now, so who’s paying that Chelsea rent, because it’s not cheap on one PR salary and a Housewives check after glam and agents eat it up. Unless there’s something to the Equinox rumors. I’m just asking.

Carole, Carole, Carole — She Wasn’t Screaming It

Carole drank a lot and left her car at Erin’s, so Erin drives it back downtown, and Carole sits down and mimics Sai’s “Carole, Carole, Carole.” And I’m so glad production included the actual tone Sai used, because now the audience can see it. Was it annoying? Maybe. Was she screaming it across the room like Carole plays it? No. This is the micro and macroaggression a lot of y’all are clocking. Carole plays elitist and down to earth at the same time, and it reads inauthentic. I was not excited about her coming back this season, and nine episodes in, I still don’t care for what she’s brought. She’s found one analogy, the onion, that I don’t even think is that good, and she keeps running it. Then she says she’s “not Sai’s teenage daughter,” and leave that kid out of it, because if she’d just said child I’d feel differently. And notice the pattern. She told Daisy “you’re more like me,” and now she’s telling Erin the same thing. What is that giving? Out on the street a blurred man says “Epstein files,” and look, this is New York, but I would not put it past production to send a PA in. Erin defends her, and Carole wonders if this will always be a footnote.

Never Miss a Story
Get the Latest
Delivered.

New stories and videos every week — straight to your inbox. Pop culture, uncensored.

Who Talks About the Party in Front of the Person Who Wasn’t Invited?

Daisy and her sister at the popcorn apartment was great TV, and this is why I say Daisy’s side stories are good. Her sister left a rich doctor husband for a 28-year-old Cuban firefighter, and Daisy’s whole position is why not just have an affair, which, Daisy, what are you telling on yourself? Mind you she’s saying all this in front of her son, then pivots into the fish-guy battle, because her fish guy is apparently where Sai’s fish guy gets his fish. That’s the New York I want, not Daddy Warbucks, just who has the better fish market. But the real moment is Erica’s birthday. Daisy finds out she wasn’t invited, and she was on the phone Kikiing and gossiping with Erica that same day. That feels produced to me, because if I’m not fussing with you I’m also not on the phone with you, so I think Erica would’ve invited her. Then at Encore’s comedy event, the hungover women gush about the party in front of Daisy, who is seething, and she asks who talks about a birthday in front of someone who wasn’t there. The episode ends with Sai arriving and the two of them bracing for a confrontation. Can these two ever be friendmies, or are they just not each other’s people? Let me know. Here we go.

How would you rate this one?

Disclaimer: This post is based on publicly available information and credited sources. All allegations are unproven